Matoli's Pizza & Subs

Experience delicious deep dish pizza, flavorful calzones, and hearty subs at Matoli's Pizza & Subs in Hernando Beach, FL. Savor homemade dough, signature white pizza, Greek salads, and cannolis. Call +1 352-592-7787 today!

View MenuContact

Welcome to Matoli's Pizza & Subs

Experience the finest dining

Matoli's Pizza & Subs
Matoli's Pizza & Subs
Matoli's Pizza & Subs
Matoli's Pizza & Subs

Matoli's Pizza & Subs welcomes food lovers to a delightful dining experience in Hernando Beach. Located at 3211 Shoal Line Blvd, this eatery specializes in Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, featuring a crust that boasts a perfect balance between chewy and crispy. The menu includes enticing options like calzones and substantial hoagies, along with a selection of delectable desserts such as cannolis and cheesecake. Each dish comes from homemade dough, ensuring freshness in every bite. Matoli's is not just about food; it's about community, where locals gather, share stories, and celebrate good times over delicious slices. Whether it's a casual lunch or a family dinner, Matoli's delivers a friendly atmosphere and a mouthwatering variety that keeps diners coming back.

Matoli's Pizza & Subs focuses on delivering exceptional food and a welcoming ambiance. Customers rave about the deep-dish pizza, especially the meat lovers variety filled with savory toppings. The restaurant's unique special pizzas, including the Eggplant and Matoli Mega Supreme, step outside the typical pizza offerings, engaging adventurous eaters. For those leaning towards healthier options, the Greek salad adds a refreshing twist to the menu. The family-friendly atmosphere emphasizes warmth and camaraderie, making it a great spot for groups or gatherings. Plus, with a diverse menu comprising 29 dishes, everyone can find something appealing. Don't miss the heavenly desserts—cannoli and Mississippi Mud Pie offer a perfect sweet ending to any meal.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

3211 Shoal Line Blvd, Hernando Beach, FL 34607, United States

Phone

+1 352-592-7787

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Matoli's Pizza & Subs
Matoli's Pizza & Subs
Matoli's Pizza & Subs
Matoli's Pizza & Subs

Matoli's Pizza & Subs stands out among Hernando Beach's culinary landscape. Established with a vision to serve authentic Chicago-style pizza, Matoli's quickly became a local gem. The commitment to using homemade dough and high-quality ingredients shines through in every dish. Guests often share stories of their favorite meals, from the hearty chicken parm hoagie to the rich, deep-dish calzone. The restaurant places a strong emphasis on customer service, ensuring everyone feels like part of the family.

In addition to the iconic pizzas, Matoli's offers a wide variety of other Italian-American favorites. Options range from classic spaghetti to stuffed shells, providing something for every palate. Each meal caters to both traditionalists and those looking to try something new, such as the innovative Breaded Chicken Pizza.

Matoli's Pizza & Subs

The exterior of Matoli's Pizza & Subs reflects its friendly, down-to-earth vibe. The restaurant has a casual style with inviting decor that beckons patrons inside. Outdoor seating provides a perfect spot to enjoy your meal while soaking in the beautiful Hernando Beach weather. During peak times, the lively atmosphere buzzes with laughter and conversation, as families and friends gather to share good food and good times. The space offers an ideal setting for both intimate meals and larger gatherings.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday12-9 PM
  • Monday12-9 PM
  • Tuesday12-9 PM
  • Wednesday12-9 PM
  • Thursday12-9 PM
  • Friday12-10 PM
  • Saturday12-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

One of the best pizza places we have been to in a long time! We ordered deep dish pizzas and they are truly deep dish, not being skimpy with the toppings. They were absolutely delicious! The eggplant parm was also so good and could've fed 3 people. You can tell the owner takes pride in what he does and the food he makes. It was a joy talking to him.

D
Diana S.

This was one of the best pizzas that I have ever had! It was loaded to the top of the mountain with fresh veggies and the most delicious meets. The owner Matt greeted us handed us our pizza and it was very evident that he made this pie with nothing but proud Joy being there for multiple decades.

L
Liz R.

Such great pizza! The only place in the area with Chicago deep dish and it did not disappoint! The sauce has a really nice sweetness to it. We also got the Greek salad and it was huge! The garlic cheese bread is good as well! It's only a grab and go place. Will definitely be back!

M
Madison G.

Awesome pizza, Awesome subs. Wonderful staff. From the phone call in to delivery. (We always get delivery), but everyone super friendly. Highly recommend! OMG! Haven't been here in awhile & decided to pick up a Philly Cheese Sub. Completely loaded & delicious! Can't think of getting it anywhere else now. Matoli's makes the best food! Thank you so much!

L
Lysa M.

This is a great place for pizza! It is hard to find deep dish pizza, which is our favorite. So glad we tried the deep dish meat lovers pizza...It was wonderful! Nice to have this restaurant very close to home...We will definitely be repeat customers!

S
Stephanie H.

New to Hernando Beach and desperate to find comfort food... found absolute bliss with the pizzas we had delivered! The White Pizza and the Meat lovers Chicago style were both a perfect choice. Delivered hot and fast. Well not hesitate or think twice about ordering here again.

B
Baby C.